Hi friend,
Hereâs one simple action you can take to help end discrimination against fat bodies this week: Believe fat people when we say something is fatphobic, specifically the works of BrenĂ© Brown, Anita Johnston, Geneen Roth and Bessel van der Kolk.
This discussion is always fraught, so Iâm setting some very firm boundaries. I will not detail to you how these folksâ work is fatphobic (though I may consider doing so at some point in the future). I will not entertain you telling me these works do not contain fatphobia or that I should âtake what is goodâ from them. It is not on fat folks to contact these authors or change their hearts or minds. Do not email me with these things; I will delete them unread past the point where they violate these boundaries.
Whenever these authors are brought up in HAES and body-positive spaces, the conversation generally looks like dozens of thin (white) women chiming in to talk about how magical and life-changing and etc. etc. their books are, while the fat folks are gritting their teeth and wondering if itâs worth being the lone voice noting that, hey, thereâs a lot of fatphobia in there too and that furthers our oppression.
And generally when one of us speaks up, the reaction is of hurt outrage thatâs honestly pretty disproportionate. It seems like yâall have invested part of your identities into these people and these works, and are unable to even consider our words. And then you lash out at the marginalized person, further harming them.
I am not â and no one else is â saying that you are a bad person for reading and liking and finding useful tools in problematic works (or people). If these authors helped you recover from an eating disorder, thatâs wonderful. You do you.
All I ask is that you believe fat folks when we speak, examine the ways in which your privilege might lead you to not see or ignore fatphobia, and stop recommending problematic works to clients, patients and friends.
âTake what is good, and leave the rest.â
Itâs a privilege to be able to take what is good and leave the rest.
A common response when fat folks object to fatphobia is, âWell, just take what is good and leave the rest.â or, âWell, I just ignored the fatphobia.â Statements like these generally come from people in average-sized or thin bodies.
Today, Iâd like you to step back and consider the amount of privilege needed both to make statements like those and to be able to look past bigotry and stigma, particularly if itâs not aimed at people like you.
If you think that itâs worth reading fatphobic books â like the works of the three authors above â for the rest of the content, examine what it might be like to read that same book when YOU are in the body that is despised. What might it be like to know that at any moment you might be reminded that the author fears and hates people like you and thinks you shouldnât exist?
Suggesting that oppressed people should just put up with a modicum of oppression in order to gain some kind of greater good from a work isâŠwell, itâs a look, thatâs for sure. How much fatphobia, exactly, should I be okay with? Is there a recommended percentage?
Or is the real situation that your deep discomfort with learning your favorite works are oppressive is more important than fat folksâ liberation, so your real desire is for fat folks to hush about fatphobia so that you can keep praising your faves to the sky without either feeling guilty or having to deal with those angry whiny fatties again?
I talk about thin privilege not to make you feel bad or guilty or ashamed, but so that we can change the world. This is one way to get started.