Hey First name / friend,
I hope you enjoyed last week's
book review of Unwind by Neal Shusterman! Did any of you happen to buy some of my
Miles & Breaker books last week? I saw a huge, random spike in Miles & Breaker sales this last week, and I genuinely have no clue where it came from 😂 Thank you for your support!
This week, I want to talk about star ratings for books. Normally, when we post book reviews, we also give the book a rating between one and five stars.
But we all have different book rating systems. No website illustrates that more dramatically than Goodreads, where reviewers are known for being unforgiving and stingy with those 5 star reviews!
Did you know that many advertisers will not accept a book with an average rating of below 4.3 stars? So, if you give a book 4 stars, you will be lowering its overall rating in many cases, which directly affects the author's ability to market the book.
Now, I'm not saying to only ever hand out 5 stars — there's plenty of books that don't deserve 5 stars. I have plenty of 4 star, 3 star, even 2 star reads in my history. But, as readers, we have the responsibility to make sure we are judging our reads fairly.
I screenshotted an amazing explanation of
the star rating system that major book advertisers use from
teylarachelbranton.com and added it to my reading journal! You can read the whole explanation in the picture below. Here's a quick summary of the content:
- 5 stars: Enjoyable, no major problems, would recommend to others
- 4 stars: Liked, still finished quickly, but had at least one major issue (didn't like the plot, writing style, major unresolved plot hole)
- 3 stars: wouldn't recommend unless it was the only book someone had available and they were stuck in an airport for two hours
- 2 stars: did not enjoy, you also feel others would not enjoy. At least 3 major issues
- 1 star: the author should throw the book in the garbage and quit writing forever
So, the next time you're rating a book, try to remember this system. And, when in doubt, round up that star rating! 😊