Emerie Roberts sank onto her beach blanket at Holly Grove Islandâs annual New Yearâs Eve bonfire. The flames licked high, waving in the gentle breeze and casting their orange glow over the native islanders and a smattering of tourists gathered around the fire.
âWhatâs with the face, sugar plum?â Sinclair Buchanan nudged Emâs shoulder. Sinâs East Carolina accent got a bit twangier with each celebratory drink. âYou look like someone done kidnapped your dog and stole your man.â
Em didnât have either, but she got the point of Sinâs colorful statement.
The New Yearâs Eve Bonfire had always been the highlight of her year, but tonight, she couldnât muster her usual enthusiasm.
âIâm fine.â Emerie forced a smile, hoping to dispel the growing concern on Sinclairâs face. Her gaze drifted toward where her longtime best friend, Nicholas Washington, was chatting up some tourist.
Nick was an exec at the local resort and a talented drummer. He was smart, handsome, and Holly Grove Islandâs resident playboy. He seemed to have eyes for every pretty, single girl whoâd graced the islandâexcept for her. To Nick, she would always be one of the guys.
âSo this is about our discussion on Christmas Eve.â Sin lowered her voice, her gaze following Emâs. âYou still havenât told Nick how you really feel about him?â
âShh!â Em hushed her friend, glancing around to see if anyone mightâve overheard.
âIâll take that as a no.â Sin heaved a sigh. âYou said you were going to talk to him.â
âI said Iâd think about talking to him,â Em reminded her. âAnd for the past week, I havenât been able to think of much else.â
âListen here, Emerie Roberts . . .â Sin burrowed her red plastic cup in the sand, then held Emâs hands in hers. âYou are so sweet and kind. You go out of your way to take care of the people you love: family, friends, neighbors. I admire that about you, Em. But itâs time you do something for yourself. So think about this and answer honestly . . . what is it that you want, sweet pea?â
The sting of tears pricking Emâs eyes came on suddenly. She swallowed hard, refusing to let them fall.
She was the last unmarried member of her high school friend group. Something Em had become increasingly aware of with each engagement party, wedding, baby shower, and christening.
Em leveled her gaze with Sinâsâ who patiently awaited her response. She held up the other womanâs hand, her engagement ring sparkling in the moonlight.
âI want what you and Rett have.â Em nodded toward her cousin, who was Sinâs fiancĂŠ. âAnd what Dex and Dakota have.â She indicated her oldest brother and his wife, who was Sinâs best friend. It was something sheâd been afraid to admit, even to herself. But a part of her was glad she had Sin to confide in. Sinclair wasnât just a friend. Em regarded her and Dakota as older sisters. âIâm the only person on this island who isnât moving forward with their life. Iâm stuck in this holding pattern, spinning my wheels.â
âThat isnât true.â Sin squeezed Emâs hand, her voice filled with compassion. âYouâve come a long way, too. You made a major career change and started your own business. And your clientele is growing.â
âTrue.â Em had worked in accounting at a factory off island where sheâd dreaded every single minute of her day inside her windowless office. Two years ago, sheâd started picking up freelance graphic design jobsâ utilizing the discipline sheâd minored in and truly had a passion for. Six months ago, the business had grown enough that sheâd quit her job and become a full- time entrepreneur.
âYou took a calculated risk with your career. And youâre much happier now because you had the courage to go after what you wanted.â
âTrue,â Em said again.
Her brows furrowed as Nick flashed the effortless smile that no single woman in his orbit could seem to resist. Miss Ohio or Michigan, or wherever it was heâd said she was from, giggled and tossed her blond box braids over one shoulder.
âSo tell Nick how you feel about him,â Sin urged. âYes, the conversation will be uncomfortable. And I understand that the possibility of things changing between you two is probably terrifying. But bottling up your feelings for Nick isnât healthy, hon.â
âWhat if I tell Nick, and he doesnât feel the way I do?â
Sheâd posed the same question to Sin a week ago. Unsurprisingly, Sinâs response hadnât changed.
âThen at least youâll know, and you can move on. Besides, as my granny always said, âClosed mouths donât get fed.â So put on your big girl panties and tell that man how you feel. Now. Or you will always regret not doing it.â
Em inhaled deeply. Sin was right. What if Miss Midwest was the woman who finally persuaded Nick Washington to settle down? She would be devastated that she hadnât been brave enough to shoot her shot.
âI canât win if Iâm not in the race, right?â Em mumbled more to herself than Sin.
âDamn straight.â Sin raised her red cup, then took a sip.
âOkay. Iâll talk to Nick. Tonight.â
âThattagirl!â Sinclair hugged her tight.
Em leaned into it, needing the reassurance.
âEverything okay?â Rett ambled over.
Her cousin was cool and laid-back. The perfect complement to Sinâs fiery, high- energy personality. One of the many reasons they were so perfect for each other.
âEverything is fine. Em and I were just having a little girl talk.â Sin extended her free hand. âHelp a girl up?â
Rett pulled Sin to her feet and into his arms. She rewarded him with a tender kiss.
âI love you two, but youâre annoyingly adorable,â Em grumbled, and they both laughed.
âSorry?â Rett shrugged.
âYouâre blocking my view of the bonfire with your PDA; go enjoy your soonâtoâbeâwedded bliss on your own beach blanket,â Em teased.
Rett grinned. âLove you, kid.â
âLove you, too, cuz.â Em grinned as they walked away, hand in hand.
Rett and Sin had been mortal enemies with secret crushes on each other back when their best friendsâ Dexter and Dakotaâ had dated in high school. While helping to plan the coupleâs wedding earlier that year, theyâd gotten to truly know each other, and theyâd fallen in love.
Em was at the Christmas Eve party last week when Rett proposed to Sin and gifted her with a fur babyâ an adorable black- and- white Havapoo puppy named Stella. She was happy for them. Still, she couldnât help wishing that her happy ending was at least on the horizon.
Em folded her arms and placed them atop her knees as she stared into the bonfire, replaying her conversation with Sinclair.
What if I tell Nick and he doesnât feel the way I do?
Then at least youâll know. And you can move on.
But moving on seemed more frightening than holding on to her unrequited feelings for Nickâ an agony to which sheâd become accustomed.
âHey, Em, whatâs wrong?â Nick settled onto the blanket beside her; his dark eyes narrowing with concern. He draped an arm over her shoulders, as he had so many times before, oblivious to his effect on her.
Her temperature rose as the warmth of his skin penetrated hers through their light jackets. Her heart beat faster as she inhaled Nickâs familiar, subtle citrus and cedarwood scent. His wide shoulders and broad chest shielded Em from the chilly breeze blowing off the Atlantic Ocean.
âYouâre not yourself tonight. Youâre usually hoisting the cornhole trophy by now, but I havenât seen you pick up a beanbag once. You werenât even into the sing-along, which you love. And Iâm pretty sure youâve only had one plate tonight, so something is definitely wrong.â
âWho are you, my mother?â Em groused, her eyes squeezing shut involuntarily as she settled against her best friend, her skin on fire and her pulse racing. âMaybe Iâm just tired. Did you consider that?â
Em opened her eyes, turning to look at him.
Big mistake.
Bathed in the soft moonlight and the glow of the raging fire, the man looked like a freaking god with his cocoa brown skin; soulful, dark eyes that managed to be both warm and mysterious; and a half smile that always hinted at mischief or some tightly held secret. All he lacked was a thunderbolt or maybe the Tesseract, if Zeus and Loki werenât using them.
âCâmon, Em.â Nickâs dark eyes glinted. His voice was a low, sensual whisper that sent a shiver down her spine and created a shudder in a place she was trying really hard not to think about right now. âI know when somethingâs up with you. Might as well spill it because you know Iâll figure it out.â
True.
From their meeting as kids, he seemed to understand her in a way no one else did. Even when sheâd been reluctant to express how she was feeling about something, Nick had always been so perceptive. Heâd been there through everything from mean girls teasing her because she was a tomboy to her first crush and every relationship that had crashed and burned since. Heâd been there through the rough patches in her parentsâ marriage and their eventual
divorce.
So how was it that Nick managed to know her so well, yet seemed clueless about her falling for him?
Sheâd realized that she was attracted to her best friend during their vacation together in Mexico five years ago. But sheâd moved back to Holly Grove Island, and heâd lived in Los Angeles at the time. It had seemed best to ignore her perplexing new feelings for Nick.
But they were now in their thirties, living in the same city for the first time since college. They spent most of their free time hanging out together. So it was getting harder to ignore the romantic feelings sheâd developed for her childhood friend.
Nothing about Nickâs demeanor suggested he felt the same.
âCâmon, Em. Whatever it is . . . you can tell me.â Nick leaned in, his face inches from hers. His warm breath, carrying a hint of whiskey and some sort of pie, mingled with the cool, crisp sea air, creating steam. âIf someone upset you, point him out. You know Iâve got you.â
A pained smile curved Emerieâs lips. She and Nick had met when Dexter and Dakota brought them along on their date to see an animated childrenâs film. She was Dexâs little sister. Nick was Dakotaâs next- door neighbor, whom she looked after when his parents were away on business. They became friends instantly, and despite already having three older brothers, Nick assumed the role of her protector.
Theyâd attended college on opposite coasts. Yet, Nick had been ready to hop on a plane or drive across the country anytime she needed him. She was a grown woman fully capable of taking care of herself. Yet, Nickâs sense of protectiveness hadnât waned.
âItâs not like that.â Em stared into the fire. âSo donât go breaking out the boxing gloves, Baby Creed.â
âBut it is something.â Nick didnât address the Creed movie reference, which he always found irritating.
Was it her fault Nick looked like Michael B. Jordanâs long- lost cousin?
âSo whatâs going on with you tonight? The bonfire is your favorite event of the year.â
Em drew in a deep breath, her eyes squeezing shut. Her heart pounded as Sinâs words echoed in her head.
Then at least youâll know.
âNo one has done anything to upset me, Nick.â Em wrapped her arms around her knees. âItâs just . . .â The sound of rushing blood filled her ears, dampening the sound of the swirling wind and the waves crashing against the shore of Holly Grove Island Beach. âI like someone, and Iâm not sure how they feel about me.â
âYouâre wondering if you should say something first.â Nick rubbed his whiskered chin and nodded knowingly.
âSomething like that.â Em waved and smiled at Marcus and Elliot: two locals heading back inside Blaze of Glory.
âBut itâs neither of those guys, right?â Nick tipped his chin by way of greeting but didnât smile at either of them. âBecause Marcus is a dick and Elliot is a mamaâs boy.â
âYouâre terrible, Nick.â
Heâd always been able to make her laugh when she was uneasy about something. From a bad case of nerves before the fifth- grade spelling bee to a near- meltdown before a big client presentation two weeks ago, Nick could always get her to relax and reset.
âMaybe, but I didnât hear you say I was wrong about them.â Nick stretched out on Emâs blanket. âSo please tell me itâs neither of those knuckleheads.â
âIt isnât.â
âOkay. But it is someone.â Nick propped himself up on the blanket as he glanced up at her. âIs it Derrick? Or Paul down at the garage? Wait . . .â He bolted upright and frowned. âYou realize Blaze is way too old for you, right?â
âNo, he isnât. Heâs like forty- five.â
âAnd youâre thirty- one,â Nick noted. âDonât get me wrong, Blaze is a great guy. Heâd give you the shirt off his back. Butââ
âItâs not Blaze or Derrick or Paul, all right?â Em huffed. She turned to face her friend, her heart thudding in her chest and her hands trembling. âItâs you, all right?â
âMe?â Nickâs eyes went wide, and he poked a thumb to his chest as he whispered the word. He stared at her as if he was awaiting the punchline of a poorly delivered joke. When she didnât respond, Nick rubbed his forehead and cleared his throat. âOh.â
Not the response I was hoping for.
This confession of love was an absolute disaster. She should say something, but she wasnât quite sure what. It was too early to claim itâd been an April Foolsâ joke. The few torturous seconds in which neither of them spoke felt like millennia. Heat spread through Emâs chest and filled her cheeks. Her breathing was quick and shallow.
Was this what a panic attack was like?
It felt like a whale had washed ashore and rolled onto her chest. She focused on the sounds of the waves hitting the shore, the laughter of their friends and neighbors, and the crackling of the fire as it consumed the wood.
Sheâd finally admitted her feelings for Nick. There was no turning back. Sheâd been surprised by her initial attraction to her best friend. Maybe Nick needed to sort through his feelings for her, too.
âYes, you, Nick.â Emerie forced her eyes to meet his and struggled to keep her lips from quivering and her hands from shaking. âYou really havenât ever thought of me that way?â
Nick winced, his brows furrowing.
Em knew her friend well, too. The apology in his expression was a clear negative response. Her stomach twisted in knots, and her cheeks stung with embarrassment.
âEm, youâre my best friend. You know how much you mean to me. That I would do anything for you. But . . .â
âBut youâre not into me like that.â Em whispered the words beneath her breath, saying them more to herself than to him. She swallowed hard and nodded. âI get it.â
âYouâre beautiful, fun, amazing. Any guy would be lucky to have you, Em.â Nick squeezed her arm.
âAny guy but you, right?â Em blinked back the tears that burned her eyes. She sniffled. âRoger that.â
âThere are a lot of things I do well, Em. Being in a serious relationship isnât one of them. The friendship we have . . . We canât risk losing that. I canât risk losing you.â
Nick pointed at himself, then at her. âYouâre the smart, sensible one, Em. So deep down, you know what Iâm saying is true.â He nudged her shoulder.
The temperature seemed at least ten degrees colder. Em shivered in response to the sudden chill deep in her bones.
Donât freak out. Just play it cool.
âYouâre right. Of course.â She forced a smile. âIt was the alcohol talking. Letâs just pretend this conversation never happened.â
âThatâs probably best,â Nick agreed.
His phone vibrated, as it so often did with text messages or phone calls. It seemed like the perfect cue for her to take her leave. Em climbed to her feet and dusted the sand off the back of her jeans. âIâm gonna head inside, chat up Blaze, and get another drink. Can I get you anything?â
âIâm good. Thanks,â Nick said.
Em headed toward Blaze of Glory, eager to end the painfully awkward conversation that would forever make things weird between them.
âEm!â
She stopped, then turned around.
Nick was standing. His handsome features were marred with worry. âWeâre good, right?â
âThat whole weird, awkward conversation never really happened, right?â Em shrugged. âSo why wouldnât we be?â
âRight.â Nick tilted his head. âAnd you wonât do anything. . . impulsive tonight?â
âA sensible girl like me?â Em asked incredulously.
âDonât worry, Iâll be fine. You should go find Miss Ohio. Iâm pretty sure sheâs looking for you.â
Em hurried toward the bar. She needed a strong drink, the comfort of sinfully decadent carbs, and to forget what had just happened between her and Nick.
Why on earth had she listened to Sinclair?