A LOVE LETTER TO MY UNDERWORLD KING
by Jonathan Koe
Dear Pluto,
Last Thursday, I found myself in a deep trance, guided by a dear mentor. She asked us to look at our second chakras: the treasure chest where we stored artifacts left behind by past lovers, notebooks dedicated to past creative projects, and favorite toys from childhood that reminded us not only of the kids we once were, but perhaps always will be.
We said goodbye 11.5 years ago. The moment you turned your back behind me, stepping out of that pastry shop on Amsterdam Avenue, I knew our underworld haven was forever vanquished.
You told me that in time, we’ll find our way back to each other. Perhaps as friends.
That never happened. But I wasn’t surprised. We were, after all, never friends to begin with.
Imagine my surprise when I found a thin silver thread, reaching out of my second chakra, calling to you, wondering how you were. To unsuspecting eyes, the thread may seem insignificant. It was dull, dusty, old. And yet, for me, a gust of wind blew open the pages of our time together.
Did I mention that since you left, I’ve found a steady rock, a loyal cat, and a magic wand?
I’m happy now. I don’t know how you are. Happy, too, it seems like, from the occasional Instagram story updates.
This silver thread was an heirloom from another epoch, long gone since.
It reminded me of the first time we met in Central Park. An invisible knife made of dandelion sliced through the core of my being when you shook my hand.
You reminded me of the boy I first kissed. Except he didn’t have invisible flames jutting out from behind him. Except he didn’t nod a couple extra times each time he finished a sentence, as if agreeing with himself.
Except he wasn’t you and the earth didn’t swallow me whole the first time I met him.
It was the same silver thread that followed us everywhere for the 15 months we were in our underworld – 15 months that felt like 15 years.
Blame it on the quiet of the underground rock formations, or the quiet whispers of the hot lava that was always brewing underneath us the way Starbucks always smells of coffee in the aboveworld, or the electricity whenever our eyes met, as if we knew we were never meant for this lifetime, but perhaps future ones – I could never figure out how it was possible that every detail of our time together remains untarnished, unspoiled in my memory after all these years.
I could still taste the Green Curry you made for me the night we moved your furnitures to the apartment by the park. The subtle scent of your mom’s cologne I picked up on while sitting on the back seat of the taxi when your parents came to visit. The night I cried from dusk till dawn after you broke up with me in front of Columbia University. The shirt you wore when we saw each other in Amsterdam after months of being apart. The smile on your face after I played the middle movement of your 3-part piece.
The fine silver thread may seem like nothing to the outside world. But to me, it was all I have left of us. A small, hidden part of me tethered to an alternate dimension where the two of us are still by the kitchen counter, scotch for me, shiraz for you, slowly munching on sliced dragonfruits and pomegranate seeds laid out on your warped wooden chopping board.
In trance state, I gently lifted this thread, curious to see if anyone’s on the other side.
No one.
I slowly wound this thread around my finger.
For a second, I thought about keeping it. And then it dawned on me – I had no use for it.
You were forever out of sight. Neither friend, nor foe. Just somebody that used to mean the world to me. Somebody that used to be my entire universe.