Hey First name / friend! This is a full breakdown of how to create a storytelling content strategy in the age of AI and all-time low consumer trust—which isn't as bad as it sounds (I'll explain below). I’ll walk you through mine as an example, but ultimately this is a guide to create your own custom strategy. Fair warning: It’s a comprehensive one. If you prefer to watch a video, you can get this information in that format here. But keep this email handy as it contains the prompts for you DIY efficiently. |
|
Midway through the year can be a reckoning for entrepreneurs who got distracted, pulled in too many directions, and lost chutzpah on the way to their dream destination they so enthusiastically vision-boarded six months ago. It was for me. Before I headed out on my two-week summer sabbatical, I took time to fine-tune the path forward. As I looked through the wins and setbacks over the last six months, it felt like a tale of two brands. On one side, I’d gotten out of my comfort zone, tried new offers, and exceeded expectations on the business side. On the other, I was in serious need of a systems overhaul on the content creation side.
My immediate reaction was to jump right in. Make a daily content plan. Execute. But as a content strategist, I knew that would only be a Band-Aid. The first and most important thing I do when I’m mapping out a storytelling content plan for myself, my students, or my clients is find the guiding insight. All good strategy (aka informed planning) starts with insight—an observation backed by evidence that clarifies the most effective and efficient small, consistent actions to take every day to reach your goal in the long run. Before I started my company, StoryCraft, in 2020, I was a journalist for more than a decade. One of my roles was to find and dissect trends to discover takeaways people could apply in their real lives. I’m not talking about trends like Barbie-themed posts or the whatever “starter kit.” I’m talking about shifts in consumer behavior and preference. When you align the steps for getting what you want with the changing tide of the overall market, you sail into your goals that much smoother. For the last few months, I’ve had my journalist hat on— researching the future of online business, knee-deep in studies from industry leaders like Gartner, Sprout Social, and Brand Builders, plus my own observations from clients and students to determine the best direction. Not just for the next six months, but for the foreseeable future—as AI dominates and consumer trust hits record lows. If you’ve been looking around at what’s working for everyone else, second-guessing what you “should” be doing or questioning what the right content plan for your business is, I want to walk you through how to strategically create one you trust. I’m going to break down the storytelling content strategy I’m using for 2025–2026 as an example. But this newsletter is really about how to use the principles of strategy building to create your own— so you know the daily actions to take to get what you want from the time and energy you spend on content. We’ll walk through what professional strategists do: - Collect relevant data and observations
- Form an insight based on that data and those observations
- Turn the insight into the basis of an action plan
- Break down the plan into small, daily habits for long-term success
There is no replacement for being able to build a plan you trust—based on your goals—in a world where other people love to tell you what works for them. Let’s get into it, First name / friend. |
|
Step One: Collect Relevant Data & Observations AI & The Future Of Content For Small & Mid-Size Biz |
|
Meta is aggressively shifting toward AI-created content. This speaks volumes about the intention and direction of how the company will monetize our attention moving forward, but for now let's focus on the surge of AI bots on Meta-owned platforms. Which means by summer 2026, a significant portion of the content in your “for you” feed won’t be made by people. It will be made by bots—bots designed to entertain, respond, and farm attention. And Meta isn’t the only one creating bot profiles. Big brands with big budgets are in on it too. As we speak, companies like Unilever, Delta, Mars, and Forever 21 are creating and running AI-powered side accounts—think of them as satellite profiles created to support the main brand. Some are modeled after human influencers. Others are run by bots that post, respond, and test content—on autopilot. They’re designed to do very specific jobs: 🎯 Target niche audiences with ultra-tailored content 🧪 Test messaging, visuals, and timing to see what performs best 🗣️ Experiment with voice and tone without risking the integrity main brand 🕐 Engage 24/7 using AI agents that reply to comments, remix posts, and adapt in real time These brand-run AI satellite accounts are rarely labeled as AI or being tied to a main brand—at least not in a way that’s obvious. (That’s by design). But behind the scenes, they’re being tested, optimized, and fed by AI systems—all under the umbrella of a larger brand strategy. Did you just give you the ick? Because—same. But it also gives direction. If you’re wondering how a brand of your size and budget is supposed to stay visible and reach people in the midst of this mass influx of AI accounts, I beg you not to hit the panic button. There’s another side to this story where you come out on top. More on that in the next section, but first the first step in building your strategy: Collect data and observations. A quick Google search of your industry will tell you the trends. I like to look at studies, but if you don’t enjoy sifting through piles of raw data, media outlets often do the heavy lifting for you. Ask yourself— - What are the trends you can lead out on?
- Where are you uniquely qualified to give a unique perspective?
- Does the data match what you’re hearing in conversations with your clients, students, and readers?
This is where you’ll find original insights. See more about how you can use Meta’s AI Studio to create your own character and chat bot here. |
|
Step Two: Turn The Data Into Strategic Insights Building Trust In A Trust Recession |
|
But that’s not such a bad thing for writers, experts, consultants, creators, and people who are the face of their businesses. Consumers don’t put personal brands and companies in the same category. All I see is opportunity for entrepreneurs who can clearly articulate their ideas, value, and viewpoints authentically. The more you connect with your audience, sharing your experiences, insight, and wisdom through storytelling, the more likely they are to trust and invest in you—which brings me to the action plan: The most effective types of storytelling content now. |
|
Step Three: Turn Insights Into An Action Plan =Two Types of Storytelling Content That Build Trust & Community |
|
Based on this data—and conversations with my clients and students—my plan is to double down on creating two types of content: 1. “Why Should I Listen to You?” content. Think: results and insights into problems and problem solving. 2. “You Belong Here” content. Think: shared values, aspirations, and similar viewpoints on how to achieve success. They both demonstrate why you're a good choice: → One through skill. → The other through values and personality fit. “Why should I listen to you?” is the question every audience has in the back of their mind—which sounds harsh, but really it’s a filter. Because there’s so much information out there, the messenger matters more than ever. This kind of content doesn’t just inform like traditional educational content—it builds confidence in your judgment by showing (not just telling) your expertise. These stories give people a window into how you apply your formal credentials in real-world situations: - How do you approach persistent problems in your industry?
→ (Shows your thinking and how you solve problems differently.) - How does your background give you insight no one else has?
→ (Demonstrates your origins of your unique perspective.) - Does your process give you a track record for getting results?
→ (Demonstrates how what you do works in real life.)
You know how hiring managers don’t choose applicants based on résumés alone? They also look at intangibles: personality fit, attitude, communication style. Online audiences are no different. “You Belong Here” content is about fit: - What do you believe or value that’s different from how most people do things in your field?
→ (Helps people see how your worldview might match theirs.) - What struggles have you worked through that your audience is dealing with too?
→ (Builds trust through shared experience.) - What personality and character traits make you successful?
→ (Lets people get a feel for who you are, not just what you do.)
Together, these two story types build credibility and connection—the foundation of a strong personal brand in a low-trust future. I’ll give plenty of examples in upcoming content. |
|
Step Four: Break Down the Plan into Small, Daily Steps Creating + Distrusting Human-First Content (without burn out) |
|
To distribute this content, I’m focusing on platforms, communication styles, and formats that put human factors on a pedestal. - Longform
- Storytelling
- Showing Face On Camera
“Ten YouTube subscribers are worth a hundred Instagram followers.” If someone watches your 12-minute YouTube video, listens to your 30+ minute podcast, or reads a full email newsletter, that’s more than visibility. That’s commitment—a better predictor of loyalty and future sales than any single viral moment. I’m taking Sun’s advice. My goal is to start a YouTube channel, podcast, or Substack. I’ve also committed to more videos—long and short-form. As someone who struggled with video consistency in the past, I know the best way to commit to this goal is to start building the habit (and skill) of video creation. I’m starting small. Stupid small. So small I can’t fail, by posting one video a week. This is just one way I'm turning strategic insights into a small step I can take every day to get closer to my goal. |
|
All good strategy starts with insight. Once you have data and observations from your experience, you can form a hypothesis to reach your goal and build a plan. From there, you can get tactical: what are the small actions you can take to reach your goal based on your insights? Trial your plan for a quarter and adjust as needed until you find the system that works for you in the long run. Why a quarter? Ninety days is enough time to see if your actions are leading to the outcomes you want—but not so long that you’ve sunk too much time into something that’s not working for the long term. I hope this information helps you create a custom plan you're excited to stick with. Before you head out— Are you on YouTube, Substack, or other non–Meta-owned platforms? I’d love to hear what’s working for you off Instagram and Facebook. Hit reply and let me know. That’s all for this week. Thanks for reading! |
|
7 Hillside Road Sound Beach, NY 11789, United States |
|
|
|