The Investigator
Who Was Never There but his DNA was
A DNA profile matched an investigator who was 80 kilometres away and had never set foot at the crime scene, the storage room, or the laboratory where the DNA profile was generated. This is not a hypothetical. It is the documented finding of a case report just published in one of the world's leading forensic science journals and it is one of the most striking demonstrations of indirect DNA transfer I have encountered in the literature.

Jae Gerhard is the Principal Forensic Scientist with extensive experience in forensic biology, DNA analysis, and the provision of independent expert opinion across a wide range of serious criminal matters in Australia. 
 
I review forensic biology reports on behalf of both defence and prosecution, provide independent expert opinions, and give expert evidence in court.
 
Independent Forensic Services was established to give criminal lawyers access to forensic expertise that is genuinely independent, scientifically rigorous, and clearly communicated.
 
I work with lawyers at every stage of proceedings from initial report review through to trial.
 
If you have a matter where DNA or biological evidence is in issue, I am available to discuss it with you at any time.
Visit our LinkedIn

         18 yrs                                80 km                                0
Cold case evidence in           Distance between DNA        Times the matched   
storage before reanalysis      donor and the laboratory      individual attended any                                                                                             relevant locations          

The Case
 
In April 2006, partial human remains were discovered at a remote location and wrapped in plastic bags. The case went unsolved. Eighteen years later, the biological evidence was reanalysed using modern trace DNA methods. A complete STR profile was recovered from the surface of one of the plastic bags and uploaded to a DNA elimination database.
 
The DNA profile matched to an individual on the database, but not to a suspect, it matched to a crime scene investigator from an entirely different bureau, located 80 kilometres from the laboratory. He had never visited the crime scene, the evidence storage room, or the DNA laboratory at any point in the preceding 18 years.
 
Extensive case reconstruction eventually identified the most plausible explanation: the investigator's DNA had transferred to a colleague's clothing during routine office contact. That colleague later attended the laboratory pretreatment area without personal protective equipment and the DNA was transferred from his clothing onto the surface of the bag. 
 
The investigator never touched anything. He was simply present in the same office as someone who later visited the lab.
 

 
How It May Have Happened
 
The Possible Indirect Transfer Pathway
 
 
01 DNA deposited onto colleague's clothing
Through routine daily contact in a shared office, the investigator's DNA adhered to a colleague's clothing — an unremarkable event that occurs constantly in any workplace.
 
 
02 Colleague enters the laboratory pretreatment area
The colleague attended the DNA laboratory to deliver other case evidence. He entered the pretreatment area, wearing only a disposable mask and cap, not full PPE and remained for less than 20 minutes.
 
 
03 DNA dislodged onto evidence surface
As the colleague moved near the pretreatment bench where the plastic bags were being processed, the investigator's DNA was shed from his clothing and deposited onto the bag surface. No direct contact occurred.
 
 
04 Full STR profile obtained and matched
The contaminated sample produced a complete DNA profile. A likelihood ratio of 3.68 × 10¹⁸ was generated for this match.  This would most commonly be reported that it is greater than 100 billion times more likely to obtain this DNA profile if the investigator is the source of the DNA than if the DNA profile was obtained from another unrelated individual in the Australian population. 
 
Image item

Gao, L., Liu, Z., Ren, W., Liu, S., Di, P., Sun, H., & Liu, Z. (2026). A rare and atypical case of long-distance indirect DNA transfer: Contamination from an investigator never present at the scene. Forensic Science International: Genetics, 86, 103566. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsigen.2026.103566
The Issue for Criminal Defence
 
What Would Have Happened to a Defendant?
 
The investigators in this case had the resources, the institutional access, and the motivation to spend considerable effort reconstructing the contamination pathway.
 
They interviewed personnel, reviewed access logs, examined entry and exit records, and conducted detailed forensic analysis of the transfer mechanism.
 
A defendant does not get that investigation. In the ordinary course of a criminal prosecution, a DNA match of this strength, a likelihood ratio in the order of 10¹⁸ or greater than 100 billion would be reported, tendered, and accepted by the court. 
 
The limitations would not appear in the report. The possibility of indirect transfer would not be volunteered. 
 
That is the gap that independent forensic expertise exists to close.

Between 2009 and 2015, 16 cases of previously undetected contamination by police personnel were identified in submitted casework in one jurisdiction alone, with contamination occurring more frequently among police staff than laboratory personnel.
 
 As DNA profiling technology becomes more sensitive, the true frequency of such events is likely higher than currently reported. (Fonneløp et al., 2016)

Practical Guidance
 
Questions to Raise When DNA Is Part of Your Brief
 
→ Is indirect DNA transfer considered? This case demonstrates that transfer can occur via a colleague who briefly visited a laboratory pretreatment area. The pathway need not be obvious and it will not be volunteered.
 
→ Has the DNA elimination database been searched? In this case, searching the database was what identified the contamination. Without it, the investigator could have been treated as a person of interest. The prosecution's report should disclose whether this step was taken.
 
→ Was the evidence handled, stored, or transported in conditions that permitted contamination or DNA transfer? Eighteen years of storage, multiple handlers, and a laboratory visit by an unauthorised person all created opportunities for the transfer of DNA. Continuity documentation should be examined.
 
→ Is the DNA profile being used as a standalone evidence? The authors of this paper state explicitly that conclusions should not be drawn from a single DNA result in isolation. If that is how the prosecution intends to use the evidence, that is the argument.

Ready to Strengthen Your Defence?
 
Independent Forensic Services is led by Principal Forensic Scientist and DNA expert Jae Gerhard. 
 
Her team of highly experienced and sought after forensic experts cover a range of forensic disciplines from crime scene to court, offering unbiased, evidence-based reviews and easy to understand forensic opinion.
81-83 Campbell Street
Surry Hills, NSW 2010, Australia