Castles in the Sky
by Rick Duffy
“So, Mr. Jones, you’re interested in the swimsuit dream?”
Mr. Jones sits at the end of my sofa. “Uh, yes, Miss Waters.”
His voice cracks, obviously forced down an octave. This kid can’t be more than fifteen. He wears a baggy overcoat that’s probably his father’s—overkill for early fall. And he’s trying to grow a mustache above his sweaty upper lip, but without much luck.
I put on my business face. Juveniles don’t slip through my filters often, but it’s a risk.
The kettle whistles, and I step to the kitchenette. “Please, call me Sarah. Would you like something to drink?”
Mr. Jones clears his throat. “A beer?”
“How about some tea?”
“Okay.”
Smart kid. Choose your battles.
I return bearing two steaming cups. The curtains in my one-room are closed. Not for ambiance or intimacy, but because the fire escape makes me look cheap. My dream journal sits open on the coffee table.
I hand Mr. Jones a cup and sink into the cushion beside him. “It’s chamomile.”
“Camel meal?” He dares a sip.
I page through the journal, trying not to smile.
This particular dream is an old one, pressed on a pale blue page with a yellow border. The images are blurred and jumbled, like wildflowers in the rain. I’d labeled it pastoral. It’s of me and my old girlfriends back at the lake. I don’t stock that kind anymore. They’re slow movers. And allowing old dreams to pile up devalues the inventory.
I lower my voice. “Just so we’re clear, it’s not erotic. Those are out of your price range.”
“I know.” He sets the cup aside.
I lean down and exhale on the page, as if reviving an ember. The images shrug and unfold with a new vibrancy—faces gain depth, water ripples, sounds of laughter echo in the sun.
Mr. Jones leans in, too. After a few seconds, the splashing and giggling slows, flattens out, and stills.
“This the one, Mr. Jones?”
He gives a furtive nod.
I smile gently. “Is this your first time, Mr. Jones?”
His puffy eyes flash up. “No.” He’s a little too insistent. “But… can we go over everything first?”
“Of course. Whenever you want to use it, breathe like I did, until the smells ooze out. This one is pine-scented. Lay it close, next to your pillow, and it will bloom into your dreams.”
“Will I be someone in it? Or will I be watching, like a video?”
“In this one, you’ll be me as I dreamt it—female, blonde, a lot younger than today. You’ll see the sights I did and feel my emotions. With enough practice, you can use it as a jumping-off point for your own dream.”
“Wow,” he whispers.
I close the album. “The contract is industry standard. Once I’ve signed it over, it’s one hundred percent yours. No returns, non-transferrable. Is this acceptable?”
“Yes.”
“Fine.” Actually, he could resell it. But second-hand dreams lose value fast. “Now, I’ll just need to see some ID.”
He pauses. “ID?”
“Standard procedure. I can’t risk losing my license selling to an underage client. People can get in a lot of trouble for that. You understand.”
This also isn’t completely true. The risks are real, and the penalties steep. It’s just that I can’t get a license. Not with the kinds of dreams I sell.
He slumps inward, his oversized coat swallowing him alive. Poor kid. His ability to dream is almost gone now. But I’d given him what I wanted in the way of an introduction to black market dreams. Still, this is as far as I’m going with a juvenile. I have my principles.
“Oh dear,” I fold my hands. “Did you forget your ID, Mr. Jones?”
“Uh, yeah.” He pats his pockets. “It’s in my other one. My other coat.”
“Then why don’t we put this off for another time?”
We lock eyes for a moment. He nods and shuffles out the door.
I doubt he’ll be back, even with a fake ID. Damn. I need some sales.
Dropping onto the couch, I sip my tea and thumb through my journal, revisiting the dreams of earlier years. At fourteen, I sold my first. Commerce in unlicensed dreams is illegal, but like Mr. Jones, I’d been stretching my wings before they were clipped. All I’d received in trade was an orange soda. That, and a week’s suspension once the principal found out. Plus a month of counseling.
Only a dream about baseball. And I never even got it back.
#
When I was little, I’d bring my dreams to the breakfast table, first thing, before they thinned out. My parent’s retellings of their nightly dreamcasts were usually boring or ridiculous, at least to me, and sometimes I couldn’t help but laugh. Then my parents laughed, too.
But they’d always listen closely when I told them of my own. Once in a while, they’d say, “That’s a good one, Sarah. Let’s keep it.” We’d get the brushes and paper, and they’d help me lay it down. I was careful to get all the shapes and colors right, the people and the moods, the layering, even the feel of the air, until it had depth, until it bloomed. Then we’d press the dream in a book, careful not to crush it. There’s nothing worse than a crushed dream.
By our teens, we’re expected to outgrow such things. The dreams handed out in school pretty much guarantee it—first cartoons, then adventures and triumphs, with education mixed in, of course. All much more exciting than people produce on their own. After that, we start picking up the nightly dreamcasts, and can choose different channels. Our natural ability to dream weakens, like an atrophied muscle. We forget how.
But I loved my natural dreams. People said they were pointless, a waste of time, unhealthy. Not me. They were each original, never seen before, never seen again. They were my dreams, my art. So I kept my journal, kept adding to it, and began to learn of the underground trade.
I spent my high school graduation money to buy my first illegal dream, from a guy in a little shop that did tattoos and painted nails. You might think the most requested ones are about revenge or violence or sex. But they’re not. They’re about lost loved ones, unresolved regrets, or those desires forever out of reach—our castles in the sky.
Mine involved fishing.
I’d commissioned a dream of Dad and me at the lake. My father was an old-guard type, sober and reserved, except when it came to sports. He hooked me early. By the time I was eighteen, we had stopped fishing together—or doing much of anything—but I had always wanted to land something big, a five-pounder. “This will be the day,” Dad would say. But it never was. So I gave the man at the shop some family pictures and described how I wanted it to go.
The dream he’d delivered was perfect. The day was clear and bright, with a sweet breeze caressing the pines and a few seagulls soaring through the sky, which I thought was a nice touch. Dad and me sat quietly on the pier, the lake rippling electric in the warm sun and gulping around the supports. There was a tug on my line. I played it out. Dad dropped his reel and moved closer. “You’ve got it, Sarah. Keep going!” The fish pulled harder, and I fumbled the pole, but Dad wrapped his big, calloused hands around mine, guiding me, not taking over. A moment later, we yanked the rod, and there it was, a beautiful, plump trout, glistening like a rainbow in the sun and spray. I swung my prize onto the pier where it landed with a wonderful whomp. And we both yelled and Dad was all smiles.
That’s what black market dream workers do—bring people what they can’t get anywhere else, and can no longer find themselves. Lost wishes, forbidden hopes, or exquisite aimlessness. When I felt the joy of seeing that fish, and of my father so proud, I think that’s when I decided to become a dream worker myself.
Well, Mom and Dad did not approve.
“We’re not rich,” Dad said over his newspaper. “How can you afford the training?”
“Not in medical. You know, like an artist.”
“I’ve seen that so-called art. Pretty seedy stuff.”
“You can’t make a living on just your dreams,” Mom added.
“You always said I had talent.”
“Those ads walk a thin line,” Dad said. “‘Bring us your fantasies! Your wildest dreams!’ Come on, Sarah, we didn’t raise you to be that naïve.”
“If you’d just give me a chance—”
“To what?” He lowered his paper. “To help people live out their cheap little thrills?”
“Come on. Not every—”
He lifted his paper, covering his face. “This is not a negotiation.”
“Why is it even your decision?”
“While you’re under my roof, it is.”
I dropped the topic. And I didn’t tell them as I began meeting with the underground, making connections, practicing. But Mom found my inventory, which included some fairly erotic product. And that was that. I can’t remember if it was my decision to leave, or theirs. Maybe an ugly mix. That was eight years ago. I sometimes miss them terribly, but that bridge is burned. Now it’s a card at Christmas. A call from Mom. You know. And the conversion always goes the same:
“Is everything all right with you, Sarah?”
“Yes, Mom, I’m doing great.”
“She says she’s doing great.”
Dad says something in the background.
“Your father wants to know if you’re happy with—with everything.”
“I’m fine, Mom.”
Dad says something else. Mom is silent.
“Did Dad say something?
“No, I don’t think so.”
“Well, I have to go. I have a client coming.”
Pretty much like that. They don’t ask me back. I don’t ask to come. And we never mention my dreams.
I moved to the city, got a job, an apartment, and worked on my dreaming. I haven’t been able to make a decent custom one, like the guy did with my fish dream, so I keep on at the diner and sell my ordinaries, at least the best of them, on the side. It may not be top-shelf, world-class inventory, but a lot of this is in the marketing.
#
I walk to the diner, past the alley that runs beneath my fire escape. A colony of black cats stare from around the dumpsters. But these aren’t normal cats; they’re deformed, bulbous and hairless, like worms with legs. They hang on the walls like lichen and huddle in muculent clumps in the damp shadows. Their mouths open and close as if in a howl, but they make no sound.
I awake and reach for my journal. I can sell that one. Dark dreams have a large following. Still, I don’t want to deal with those people. They have a vibe, as if they’re holding in an awful, secret world. If I give them the slightest encouragement, they’ll share it with me, and it might seep into my own dreams, stain them. Those stains are hard to get out.
Besides, when I set down a dream, it’s difficult to destroy if I change my mind. Well, I can, of course. It’s just pressed on paper. But I feel like I’m throwing away a part of myself.
Ugh. I carefully brush the dream onto a blank, ash-colored page. I can’t afford to be picky.
It’s no wonder I had another dark one. Dreams often arise from moods, and these days mine are grim. Sales are off: maybe it’s just the times, people’s changing tastes. Or I’m not as good a dreamer as I once was, or thought I was. God, I hope I’m not losing it.
Last month, I tagged my entire catalog at a discount if bought in bulk. Rent’s going up, more than I can afford. A new restaurant opened nearby, and that means fewer customers in the diner, fewer tips. This is my “Keep a Starving Artist Off the Street” sale. I’m usually not that bold, but if I don’t make more sales soon—well, this will at least get me through a few more months.
I head down to work. There’s mail in my slot. I stuff it into my bag. Outside, the alley looks as it did in my dream, except no cats.
During lunch, I check the mail. There’s a letter from one of my better clients. I used to insist sales be done in person. Giving dreams away involves a certain intimacy, at least for me. Even though I know that’s what I’ve signed up for, I still need to look into their eyes before consummating the transaction. But the financial realities caught up with me, and now I accept mail orders.
This particular client is a real collector. He always skims off the cream of my merchandise, the vibrant, soaring dreams, and the rare, erotic ones. I smile. This could be the break I need.
The letter reads: “Dear Miss Waters, thank you for your past dreams. Each has a valued place in my collection. I see you are offering up your entire inventory at a reasonable price. I am prepared to acquire your full stock.”
I nearly choke. At last, some luck! This will keep me in the apartment for over a year, with plenty of time to restock. I keep reading. “Please let me know when to expect delivery. P.S. You have marked two of the dreams Not-For-Sale. As part of this deal, I require that you include those as well.”
The joy drains away.
Whenever I need help through the hard times, I revisit my Not-For-Sale dreams. The first is the one I had custom-made, with the fish. I list it in the inventory to show my collaboration skills with another dream worker.
The second, I dreamt after leaving home. My mood had been awful. The only apartment I could afford was a big disappointment. I had no friends here, no connections, no customer base. Everything was strange and terrifying. The perfect setup for a nightmare.
But this wasn’t a nightmare: it was a salvation. I was back in the old house, a lovely place in the western hills of Connecticut. I woke up in my old bed, on a glorious morning with the sun gilding the leaves outside my window, their shadows freckling the walls, the reflections as dancing fairies across my baseball trophies. Joy washed over me like a spring rain. I smelled bacon and coffee, heard the radio playing in the kitchen, and my father whoop as the UConn Huskies scored. Mom poked into the doorway in her faded blue apron. “Breakfast is ready, dear.”
“Hurry, Sarah, you’re missing it!” Dad yelled.
“Coming! Coming!”
I threw off the covers, hopped out of bed, and the dream ended.
It still amazes me how a simple dream, even waking up in your bed with breakfast and family waiting, can bring such joy, such peace. But it did, and it does. I think it’s the sudden, unexpected wonder in such a grey world. The tiny flowers in the crumbling sidewalks.
And now, Mr. Rodman wanted it all.
Well, business is business, and negotiation is always possible. I write back with a proposal.
#
At night, I pull out my fishing dream, breathe it to life, and as I sleep, the scene blooms in my head. Toward morning, I switch over to the back-home-again dream. That one makes me cry, every time.
I go to work as usual. All day, my mind runs over the client’s letter. Would he be open to a counteroffer, to allow me to hold on to just one of my dreams?
And if so, which? I hold them both in the deepest part of my heart. The breakfast scene has both my mom and dad together. The fishing one only has Dad, but the relationship strikes a special note, now lost. Still, bought-dreams such as that wear out quicker, and this one has already become a bit threadbare. Maybe I should let Mr. Rodman take it while it still has some value. But since I created the breakfast one myself, perhaps I could have another like it?
Five days later, a response arrives. I don’t need to choose. Mr. Rodman is insistent: all or nothing.
I read the letter a dozen times. All or nothing. It cuts into me. Letting so many of my dreams go at once is hard enough. That will leave a bitter emptiness. However, with my financial issues, I’ve come to terms with it.
But those two dreams as well? They’re powerful and precious to me. Perhaps the most precious things I have left.
And I wonder, am I making too much of this? Selling my dreams is my livelihood. Or at least I’m trying to make it that. And if I can use them to make a better life, why shouldn’t I? Isn’t that what dreams are for?
At last, I decide. I open the journal and sign away my dreams. I carefully tear them out, page by colorful page, trying to keep my tears from smudging them.
I place the pages into a nice little box along with the bill. As I do, I write a letter to go with it.
“Dear Mr. Rodman, I have enclosed my inventory of dreams. I hope you enjoy them. I have attached an invoice and terms.
“I feel I owe you an explanation of the contents. It’s a hard thing sometimes to part with one’s dreams. And I can tell you it’s even harder to watch them all go at once. So, I am sorry I cannot include those last two. They are my heart. Everything else is negotiable, but without my heart, there would be no more dreams.”
I send him the box and the letter.
#
What else can I do but wait and hope for the best?
But I’m not optimistic. My dreams are dark now, thick with anxiety. Confusing dreams with shifting landscapes and strange people. Dreams with an atmosphere of dread, or the feeling I’d forgotten something, or of some undefinable guilt. I don’t keep any of those.
A week passes. Two.
Maybe it was a stupid move, sending off my inventory without a signed contract. No help for it now—the courts certainly wouldn’t assist an unlicensed dream worker. Still, there is one point of light in the whole affair. I might lose my inventory, my apartment, even my job, but I’ve kept the dreams of my heart. And those will get me through. They always have.
What bothers me the most is the thought of phoning home for help. Any thread of family connection I still cling to will snap with the indignity of admitting to my father that I was a failure. In admitting it to myself. That I am, in the end, just some seedy dream worker weaving little thrills for people who have given up on their own dreams.
Weaving dreams for people like me.
A full month later, I receive a call.
“Hello?”
“Miss Waters?”
“Yes?”
“This is Mr. Rodman.”
I swallow. We’d never talked.
“Mr. Rodman. It’s so nice—”
“Did you mean what you said, in your letter, about those other dreams?”
“I’m sorry, but yes.”
Something nags at me. It’d been a long time, but—
He tries to say something more, but it catches in his throat. The phone shuffles, like he’s hanging up.
“Wait!” I said.
A new voice comes on. A woman.
“Sarah?”
“Mom? Mom?” I begin to cry.
“Oh Sarah, I’m—listen. Your father, he’s been saving all your dreams. And he wants me to ask you to come home.”
#
I wish I could say my dreams became the brilliant, liberating productions the world needs. But I’d be lying.
Mom and Dad helped get me back on my feet. Now, I visit whenever I can.
Today I sat on the pier with Dad. We didn’t talk much. The day was cloudy, and he lent me his jacket. The floats bobbed quietly in the choppy water. Not the most comfortable silence. We’re working on it.
My parents are right, in a way. I was naïve to think all I needed was my dreams. But I’m right, too. There’s more to life than the dreams we’re fed. We need our own unapproved, untamed, ungoverned ones. Sometimes, those are the dreams that get us through.
I still haven’t landed that five-pounder. But I’ll keep trying.
Now, I keep a blank page next to my pillow, because that’s the thing about dreams, and why we keep returning to them—you just never know what your psyche will conjure up. Maybe it will be something fragmented or disjointed or mundane. Maybe it will be a nightmare.
Or maybe, if you’re lucky, it will be a castle in the sky.
~~~
~Castles in the Sky was originally published in the 2020 anthology Wild: Uncivilized Tales from Rocky Mountain Fiction Writers~